• Subscribe to Our Newsletter

How a Lovesick Teen Plotted Her Family’s Demise

Where Is Erin Caffey Now?

Erin took a plea deal and is serving two consecutive life sentences, plus an additional 25 years. She was charged with three counts of capital murder. Even behind bars, she still would not take the responsibility that she was supposed to. You’re already behind bars, girl. Just own up to it.

Wilkinson, Waid, and Johnson are signing their deals in court.

Source: Tumblr

Her accomplices received similar sentences. Wilkinson and Waid were given life sentences without parole; they nearly received the death penalty, but Terry Caffey specifically asked to drop that as an option. Bobbi Johnson received 40 years for being involved without using a weapon.